jump to navigation

Babies “cry it out” over the use of unsustainable parenting methods December 2, 2008

Posted by Megan in Uncategorized.
trackback

Sustainability is the word of the moment, along with that other word I have grown to hate hearing ‘Un-precedent’. So to use these two in combination we in our current situation of the world today have ‘Un-precedent Un-sustainability’. Our resources are diminishing we are imploding in a pone ourselves as a species. In the past 100 to 200 or so years this craze of selfishness has excelled beyond most of our comprehensions.  

 

I would bring up a thought that someone had, who is very pro-cry it out… “all I have to say, is that, do you know that that our generation is one of the most self-absorbed, narcissistic, selfish generations that has ever been? I doubt that that’s because we were neglected/controlled/forced (whatever you want to call it) so often throughout infancy and childhood.

Many of you like husband  and myself might nod in agreement in part of what this person has said but stumble over the “I doubt” part…re-read then shake your head and smile at how the commenter has missed why children are they way they are. These ‘qualities’ within ourselves are one of the main keys to what has been our demise as humans the past few generations.

 

AND it is these ‘qualities’ that are some of the reasons why parents like myself parent the way we do. Because they are sick of how the ‘rest’ of the world is…selfish, greedy, self centered, non-committing, un-empathetic, narcissistic…and often just downright rude and mean.

 

Many people in our world today wonder why we have got into such a situation. Why are there children killing children, why is there such violence in our lives, why do so many not seem to care how much they use and consume. Why is our emotional intelligence so low which lowers our ability to work together, think about each other’s feelings and work together as a team….thus comes the uncaring about our world and the resources.

Many of us have wondered and many of us have looked at ourselves and others around us…and some of us have decided that it is ‘us’ that is the problem and we need to teach our children in a different way. Our different way is teaching from the beginning good habits, caring habits and thoughtful habits often called Attachment Parenting.

 

Children are true mirrors of the people who care for them. This mirroring starts at a very early age which is why so much research has been done on the 0-3 age and has been deemed so important. If we look at the brain development of an infant (Graph put together from information from the Brain Wave trust and Wisconsin Council on Children and Families)

 

stages-of-brain-development-in-an-infantWe can see Emotional Development and Social Attachment Skills are developed and honed from the day we are born. These pathways in the brain which can be linked by positive occurrences in an infant’s life making strong synapse links (Postnatal brain development takes place from the bottom up. The brain stem and midbrain which monitor the involuntary functions are the first to develop, as they are crucial for the survival. The last parts to eventually develop are the limbic system which controls the emotions and then the cerebral cortex, which is the organ of cognitive controls….more) (Nature, Nurture and Early Brain Development) with healthy responsive parenting. Or they can be eroded or not even made by neglect or unresponsive parenting; this can lead to an infant growing into an adult who has low emotional intelligence.  Some links to my other posts Babies and Children forced into independence , and my other posts which might contain empathy

These parts of our brain are set up for life and yes while our brain can change and develop with help it is not until later that the adult may realize that there is something wrong or a miss and starting out ‘right’ is much much easier.

 

The parenting style which used ‘Cry it out’ as a ‘tool’ or technique to ‘teach’ an infant to sleep is missing out on some of the most fundamental  aspects of human biology and brain development.

This parenting style shuts off the interaction needed for the ‘good’ development of these areas as well as setting themselves up for a life of un-empathetic communication with their children. As how do you once you’ve started down the road of the blocking out of human cries of fear do you after a few years change to listening (and the stage of development which is important for that listening is past in the infants development).

 

Empathy is one of our keys to unlocking or slowly removing our issues of Un-precedent Un-sustainability. Empathy and Education.

 

We have changed from the days of living cave man style – which some might be saddened over that loss of community collectiveness and attunement – to living as they say ‘life in the fast lane’.

Today we live alone or in very small family units some unknowing even where the milk comes from before it got in the carton let alone what it takes to put it there.

Living this modern singular life of as little emotional and environmental interaction as possible leads us as human infant to grow up as distant unthinking and uncaring adults.

Which is why we as parents are the leaders – the protectors – of our environment as we teach our children empathy and knowledge which is learnt and remembered from the day we are born.

 

Some good reading:

·         Sears “The Successful Child” a good quote from this book is “Your success in life, (Jim and Bob,) will not be measured by the money you make of the degrees you earn, but rather by the number of persons whose lives are better because of what you did.”

·         Meredith F. Small “Our Babies, Ourselves – How biology and culture shape the way we parent” to read an interview about our brain size and developoment.

·         Daniel Siegel and Mary Hartzell’s book “Parenting from the Inside Out” - also to read one of my posts on the different types of attachment

 

 

Where do you learn empathy but from your parents showing you empathy. If you feel that letting your infant scream itself to sleep is ok cause they are too young to know any better (which many intelligent researchers will tell you that this is NOT true) what about the people around you who hear it; your older children, your partner, your friends and their children – where are you showing that you care? How do you think the excuses of “but he/she needs to learn how to sleep on their own” goes down…really? Truly a child is crying…that child needs attention. 

Comments»

1. Adrianne - December 2, 2008

I totally agree with you! This example comes to mind:
If you came over to my house and you could hear my husband upstairs crying. The crying got louder and louder, and my only response was “Oh he’ll eventually tire himself out and fall asleep”. That would never happen because we all know that adults don’t cry without reason, so why do people think that it is any different for a baby? Babies have emotional needs just like the rest of us and these needs MUST be met. This is how we lay the foundation for healthy emotional development.

2. Sandra - December 2, 2008

BLESS YOU!

I am a very VERY outspoken hater of the CIO method, and was thrilled to see a mainstream publication (someone emailed me, I do not subscribe) actually explain why loving a baby isn’t spoiling a baby: http://www.todaysparent.com/baby/behaviordevelopment/article.jsp?content=20081027_134032_13100&page=1

They say that research shows (I hate that – to me, NATURE PROVES, but I digress) that those children that were responded to within seconds actually cry less than those Americanized ones who are neglected and left to cry on their own.

I love it when the mainstream media gets something right! :D

3. Erin - December 17, 2008

Nice post! Reminds me of my favorite book by Sue Gerhardt called Why Love Matters: How Affection Shapes a Baby’s Brain. If you haven’t read it, I bet it would be right up your alley.

4. Vintage Mama's Rants » Blog Archive » Why you should never let your baby CIO (Cry It Out) - November 6, 2009

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.